Ryobi P238 vs P290 Real Insights That Surprise You
Ryobi P238 vs P290: Which Impact Driver Fits You Best?
If you’re torn between the Ryobi P238 vs P290, you’re not alone. Both are fan-favorites in the DIY and pro-tool world, but they shine in slightly different ways. In simple terms, the P238 delivers brushless power for smoother performance, while the P290 offers great value with a solid brushed design.
Based on expert research and real user insights, this guide breaks down how these two stack up in performance, comfort, and price—so you can pick the one that truly fits your needs. Whether you’re a weekend DIYer or a contractor who relies on tools daily, you’ll find clear answers here.
In short, this comparison gives you an easy-to-read, no-fluff breakdown of Ryobi P238 vs P290, helping you make a confident choice without guesswork.
Ryobi P238
I explored different sources to understand this product better and share a clear, simple view. This tool has a strong mix of power, comfort, and smart design. It’s easy to use and fits many kinds of projects, big or small.
What is Special About This
The Ryobi P238 stands out for its mix of strength, control, and comfort. It’s part of Ryobi’s One+ system, which means one battery fits many tools. That makes it easy and budget-friendly for anyone who already owns Ryobi products.
Here’s what makes it special:
- Brushless Motor: Gives more power, uses less battery, and lasts longer than brushed types.
- Three Speed Modes: Helps adjust the power for small, medium, or tough jobs.
- Tri-Beam LED Lights: Brightens dark spots and cuts shadows so you can see clearly.
- GripZone Handle: Feels soft and steady in hand, even after long use.
- Magnetic Bit Tray: Keeps bits and screws close so you can work faster and stay organized.
- Compact but Strong: Delivers up to 2,200 in-lbs of torque and 3,100 RPM for heavy work.
- One+ Battery Fit: Works with over 225 Ryobi tools, adding value to your set.
The P238 blends comfort, smart features, and strong power. That’s why many people still choose it, even when newer models are out.
What Could Be Better
No tool is perfect. The Ryobi P238 has a few things that users often talk about. These points don’t ruin the experience but are good to know.
Things people might find challenging:
- Battery Use: The power can drain fast under tough or long jobs.
- Weight: It’s a bit heavier and wider than some new Ryobi HP models.
- Heat: Gets warm after long, heavy use.
- Feature Changes: Some newer models removed the magnetic tray and bit holder.
How it can be improved:
- Better cooling design could stop heat build-up.
- Improved battery control could help it run longer under load.
- Bringing back the magnetic tray would make future models more user-friendly.
- A slimmer frame could help reach tight areas.
Even with these small flaws, the P238 still gives great value. It stays reliable for home projects, car work, and light professional use.
My Personal Experience
I explored many reviews, videos, and hands-on tests to learn more about this tool. These thoughts reflect what users often say and what makes the Ryobi brand stand out.
Design
Many people like the simple and solid look of the P238. The Tri-Beam LED lights help you work in low light with fewer shadows. The GripZone handle adds comfort and grip, even when your hands are wet or dusty. The magnetic bit holder keeps screws close, saving time during fast work.
The design still has that bold Ryobi green style that people recognize. It feels strong but not clunky. While it’s a bit larger than new HP models, it gives a confident, steady feel. You can tell it’s made for real work, not just light DIY.
Performance
The P238 gives smooth and steady power for most home and garage jobs. It offers up to 2,200 inch-pounds of torque, which is plenty for long screws or bolts. The three speed settings make it easy to switch between light and heavy work.
Users often say it drives screws fast and clean, with less slipping. The brushless motor keeps power strong and helps the battery last longer. It can get a bit warm during long use, but that’s normal for tools of this size. In general, the P238 runs smoothly and feels strong.
Build Quality
Ryobi is known for solid and lasting tools, and this one fits that image well. The body feels sturdy, with a strong case and firm chuck. The trigger and switches respond well, showing care in design.
Many users say it feels “tough but balanced.” The material doesn’t feel cheap, and it holds up after years of use. It may not be the lightest or most compact, but it’s made to last.
The P238 gives a mix of power, comfort, and dependability. That’s why it remains a good choice for both DIY users and pros who want good performance at a fair price.
Ryobi P290
I explored different sources to understand this product better and to share insights that anyone can relate to. The goal was to see how this tool performs in real use, what makes it stand out, and what could be better. I looked at user opinions, expert tests, and brand details to form a clear and balanced view. This helps present the Ryobi P290 in a way that’s easy to follow and useful for both beginners and regular tool users.
What Is Special About This
The Ryobi P290 Quiet Strike is a strong and smart power tool. It stands out because it runs smooth, drives fast, and stays quiet. Many users find it useful for both home and jobsite work. It helps reduce noise while keeping great speed and strength. This makes it easy to use in small or indoor spaces.
Here’s what makes it special:
- Quiet use: The oil pulse system cuts noise by up to half. It keeps the driver calm and steady, even when working for long hours.
- Strong speed and power: It drives screws fast with up to 3,200 RPM. It can handle wood and light metal with no struggle.
- Better lighting: The Tri-Beam LED lights remove shadows, so you can see your work area clearly.
- Smart add-ons: The magnetic tray holds screws. The quick-change chuck lets you swap bits fast and without tools.
- Good grip: The rubber handle helps keep your hand steady, even when it’s wet or dusty.
- Great value: It gives quiet power at a fair price. You get near-pro quality for less money.
This mix of quiet strength and easy use makes the Ryobi P290 a favorite among both casual users and pros who want less noise and more comfort.
What Could Be Better
While the Ryobi P290 performs well, there are small areas that could use improvement. These are common points shared by users who have tried it in real settings.
Things people might find challenging:
- It feels a little large and heavy for an impact driver.
- The LED light turns off right after you release the trigger.
- The quick-change chuck can be tricky when inserting bits.
- The tool-only package means you must buy the battery and charger separately.
How it can be improved:
- A smaller body would help make it easier to handle in tight spots.
- Adding a few seconds of light delay could make dark jobs simpler.
- A smoother chuck design would help with faster bit changes.
- Offering a combo kit with a battery could attract new users.
Even with these small notes, the Ryobi P290 keeps its value strong. It stays true to Ryobi’s promise—making tools that work well, last long, and stay easy to afford.
My Personal Experience
I explored many expert reviews and user opinions to understand this tool better. The insights below come from research, testing notes, and general feedback about how this impact driver performs in real use.
Design
The Ryobi P290 has a bold and practical look. It is not the smallest tool, but its shape gives balance and control. The green color is easy to spot, and the handle fits well in most hands. The magnetic tray at the base is a handy feature for keeping screws close. It may feel heavy compared to compact models, but it also feels strong and secure. The size shows that it was built for real work, not just quick fixes.
Performance
The performance of the P290 is where it truly shines. The oil pulse system makes it much quieter than regular impact drivers. This helps reduce ear strain and stress during long jobs. Despite being a mid-range model, it drives long screws and lag bolts with smooth control. It reaches 3,200 RPM, which helps it work fast and steady. Many users notice that it keeps up well with top brands like Milwaukee and RIDGID. It shows that Ryobi can offer pro-like results without the high price.
Build Quality
Ryobi tools are known for strong builds, and this model proves that again. The body feels solid and balanced. The rubberized grip gives a safe hold and helps absorb some vibration. Users often say it feels tough and long-lasting. It may not be as light as premium compact drivers, but the build gives a sense of trust and durability. For anyone already using Ryobi’s One+ batteries, it fits right in and adds value to the set.
Ryobi P238 vs P290 Detailed Comparison
According to those who tried both tools, the Ryobi P238 and P290 each bring their own strengths. One gives strong power, the other offers quiet control. Let’s go over the real-world details so you can pick the right one for your work.
Motor Type : Ryobi P238 vs P290
The P238 has a brushless motor. It runs cooler, uses less power, and lasts longer. The P290 uses a hydraulic oil-pulse motor. It’s not brushless, but it runs smoother and makes less noise.
| Feature | Ryobi P238 | Ryobi P290 |
| Motor Type | Brushless | Hydraulic (Oil-Pulse) |
| Efficiency | High | Medium |
| Maintenance | Low | Low-Medium |
| Noise | Louder | Quieter |
Rating:
⭐ P238 – 9/10 ⭐ P290 – 8/10
Power & Torque Output: Ryobi P238 vs P290
If you need strong force, go with the P238. It gives up to 2,200 in-lbs of torque. The P290 feels softer but still drives screws with steady power.
| Feature | Ryobi P238 | Ryobi P290 |
| Max Torque | 2,200 in-lbs | ~1,400–1,600 in-lbs (est.) |
| Impacts per Minute | 4,000 | Not listed (hydraulic pulse) |
| Best For | Heavy-duty jobs | Indoor or small tasks |
Rating:
⭐ P238 – 9/10 ⭐ P290 – 7/10
Speed Settings & Control: Ryobi P238 vs P290
The P238 comes with three speed modes. You can switch speeds for different jobs. The P290 has one main mode but gives smooth and steady control.
| Feature | Ryobi P238 | Ryobi P290 |
| Speed Modes | 3 | 1 |
| Max RPM | 3,200 | 3,200 |
| Trigger Feel | Very Sensitive | Smooth and Calm |
Rating:
⭐ P238 – 9/10 ⭐ P290 – 7.5/10
Battery Compatibility & Runtime: Ryobi P238 vs P290
Both tools use the same ONE+ 18V battery system. The P238 runs longer on the same battery because of its brushless motor. The P290 uses a bit more power but still holds well for regular work.
| Feature | Ryobi P238 | Ryobi P290 |
| Battery System | ONE+ 18V | ONE+ 18V |
| Runtime | Longer | Slightly Shorter |
| Compatibility | Excellent | Excellent |
Rating:
⭐ P238 – 9/10 ⭐ P290 – 8.5/10
Size & Weight (Ergonomics): Ryobi P238 vs P290
The P238 feels light and balanced in hand. The P290 is bigger and heavier, closer to a small drill in size. It’s fine for short jobs but can feel tiring in long use.
| Feature | Ryobi P238 | Ryobi P290 |
| Weight (with 4.0Ah batt.) | ≈4.3 lbs | ≈4.8 lbs |
| Size | Compact | Larger |
| Comfort | High | Medium |
Rating:
⭐ P238 – 9/10 ⭐ P290 – 7.5/10
Design Features (Grip, Trigger, Switches): Ryobi P238 vs P290
Both tools feel sturdy and easy to hold. The P238 has a more sensitive trigger and easy speed switch. The P290 has a bigger grip, which helps when wearing gloves.
| Feature | Ryobi P238 | Ryobi P290 |
| Grip Feel | Excellent | Good |
| Trigger Control | Smooth | Steady |
| Switch Access | Easy | Slightly Firm |
Rating:
⭐ P238 – 9/10 ⭐ P290 – 8/10
LED Work Light Performance: Ryobi P238 vs P290
Both models use tri-beam LEDs. The P238 light stays on for about 10 seconds after release, which helps in dark corners. The P290 light turns off right away.
| Feature | Ryobi P238 | Ryobi P290 |
| LED Type | Tri-beam | Tri-beam |
| Light Delay | 10 seconds | None |
| Brightness | Excellent | Good |
Rating:
⭐ P238 – 9.5/10 ⭐ P290 – 7.5/10
Bit Holder & Magnetic Tray: Ryobi P238 vs P290
Both drivers have a magnetic tray and bit holder. These small features make a big difference. They keep screws close so you don’t drop or lose them while working.
| Feature | Ryobi P238 | Ryobi P290 |
| Bit Holder | Yes | Yes |
| Magnetic Tray | Yes | Yes |
| Ease of Use | Simple | Simple |
Rating:
⭐ P238 – 9/10 ⭐ P290 – 9/10
Durability & Heat Management: Ryobi P238 vs P290
The P238 stays cool even after long use. Its brushless motor helps reduce heat. The P290 gets a little warm but stays stable for light or medium jobs.
| Feature | Ryobi P238 | Ryobi P290 |
| Heat Control | Excellent | Good |
| Build Life | Long | Moderate-Long |
| Protection | Yes | Not Listed |
Rating:
⭐ P238 – 9/10 ⭐ P290 – 8/10
Price & Value for Money (2025 Market): Ryobi P238 vs P290
In 2025, both tools cost between $90 and $120 (tool only). The P238 gives more power for the price. The P290 offers quiet work for those who value comfort.
| Feature | Ryobi P238 | Ryobi P290 |
| Price Range | $89–$119 | Around $99 |
| Value for Work | Excellent | Good |
| Best For | Speed & Power | Quiet Jobs |
Rating:
⭐ P238 – 9/10 ⭐ P290 – 8.5/10
Best Use Case (Who Should Buy Which?): Ryobi P238 vs P290
The P238 is a strong choice for those who need more torque and speed. The P290 is better if you work inside or want less noise. Both tools are easy to use and fit the same Ryobi ONE+ battery system.
| Type of User | Best Pick |
| Indoor DIYers | Ryobi P290 |
| Workshop or Garage Users | Ryobi P238 |
| Power Users | Ryobi P238 |
| Quiet Tool Lovers | Ryobi P290 |
Rating:
⭐ P238 – 9/10 ⭐ P290 – 8.5/10
Final Thoughts on Ryobi
If you’re someone who values solid performance, fair pricing, and easy-to-use tools, Ryobi could be a great match for you. However, if you’re chasing premium, heavy-duty gear for daily job site use, you might want to explore pro-grade brands. From my research, Ryobi strikes a nice balance between power and practicality—perfect for DIYers and light pros who want real value without the high price tag.
FAQs for Ryobi P238 vs P290
Which is better, Ryobi P238 or P290?
Ryobi P238 is brushless and offers smoother power, while P290 is brushed and more budget-friendly. Pick P238 for heavy use or P290 for light DIY work.
Does Ryobi P238 have more torque than P290?
Yes. Ryobi P238 delivers higher torque and faster driving speed. It’s better for tougher jobs where more power and precision are needed.
Are Ryobi P238 and P290 batteries interchangeable?
Yes. Both use Ryobi’s 18V ONE+ battery system, so you can swap batteries between them easily without buying extra ones.
Which Ryobi model is lighter to handle?
The Ryobi P290 is slightly lighter and better for longer use without fatigue, while the P238 feels sturdier and well-balanced for power work.
Is the Ryobi P238 worth the extra cost?
If you need better performance and longer tool life, the P238 is worth it. But if you want a cheaper, capable driver for small jobs, go with the P290.
Read More: Ryobi P237 vs P238: Everything You Must Know Before Making a Decision