Ryobi P237 vs P238: Honest Insights That Might Surprise You
Ryobi P237 vs P238 — Which Impact Driver Is Right for You?
If you’re wondering which tool gives you more value between the Ryobi P237 vs P238, the quick answer is this — the P237 is a solid brushed model for everyday DIY jobs, while the P238’s brushless motor offers more power, longer life, and smoother control. Both belong to Ryobi’s popular 18V ONE+ line, a favorite among U.S. homeowners and weekend builders. In this guide, we’ll break down each model in simple terms so you can choose the one that truly fits your projects and budget.
The Ryobi P237 is ideal for casual use, while the P238 is better for frequent, demanding work — let’s explore why that difference matters.
Ryobi P237
I explored different sources to understand this product better and see how it performs in real use. Many users talk about its mix of power, comfort, and simple design. It’s made for people who want solid results without spending a lot. The P237 shows how Ryobi keeps tools easy to handle while still giving strong performance.
What Is Special About This
The Ryobi P237 stands out for its power, smart design, and easy use. It works well for both home projects and light professional jobs. Many users see it as a strong and simple tool that gets things done without much effort.
Why people may like it:
- Three speed settings let anyone choose the right power for the job.
- Strong torque drives long screws fast and smooth.
- Lightweight design keeps hands from getting tired during long use.
- LED lights help brighten dark work areas.
- Soft grip handle feels steady and reduces vibration.
- Good price point gives solid value for the features it offers.
- Fits all Ryobi 18V One+ batteries, which saves money and adds convenience.
These points show why the Ryobi P237 stays a trusted pick for many tool users. It mixes comfort, control, and cost efficiency in a smart way.
What Could Be Better
Even a strong tool like the Ryobi P237 has a few things that could improve. Most of these are small details, but they matter for people who use tools often.
What people might not like or find challenging:
- The LED light does not always reach tight or dark corners.
- Older features like the built-in bit holder are missing.
- The magnetic tray is smaller and holds fewer screws.
- Some users find the grip a little bulky for small hands.
- The sound at top speed can be loud in closed spaces.
How it can be improved:
- A brighter or wider LED light would make a big difference.
- Bringing back the bit holder could add extra comfort.
- A larger magnetic tray would make it easier to hold small parts.
- A slimmer handle design could fit more users.
- A bit of sound control might make it nicer to use indoors.
These updates could make the P237 even better while keeping its good price and power. Ryobi already has a strong base here, so small changes would go a long way.
My Personal Experience
I explored different sources and real user reviews to understand this product better. Ryobi has built a name for reliable, affordable tools. The P237 shows why many DIY fans trust this brand. Here’s what stands out most about its design, performance, and build quality.
Design
The Ryobi P237 follows the brand’s familiar green and black look. It’s easy to spot in a busy workshop. The handle shape gives a firm and steady grip. Many users say it feels balanced and safe to hold, even for long hours.
The controls are simple. The trigger and speed selector sit right where you need them. The magnetic tray, while smaller than older models, still helps keep screws close. The design focuses on comfort, which is why it suits both beginners and experienced users.
Performance
The P237 delivers strong, steady power. It comes with three speed settings that help control torque for any task. Many users find it smooth when driving screws or bolts. It handles wood, metal, and plastic with ease.
The trigger response is quick and even, which helps prevent stripping screws. The impact strength is enough for most home and job-site projects. It’s not the top of the line, but for its price and class, the performance is impressive.
Build Quality
The Ryobi P237 feels solid in hand. It’s made from impact-resistant plastic that can handle small drops or bumps. Inside, the metal parts keep the tool strong and stable. Users often mention that it feels sturdy but not heavy.
It may not have the premium finish of higher-end brands, but it delivers lasting reliability. For most people, it’s a dependable tool that stays useful for years of weekend projects.
Ryobi P238
I explored different sources to understand this product better and share a clear, simple view. This tool has a strong mix of power, comfort, and smart design. It’s easy to use and fits many kinds of projects, big or small.
What is Special About This
The Ryobi P238 stands out for its mix of strength, control, and comfort. It’s part of Ryobi’s One+ system, which means one battery fits many tools. That makes it easy and budget-friendly for anyone who already owns Ryobi products.
Here’s what makes it special:
- Brushless Motor: Gives more power, uses less battery, and lasts longer than brushed types.
- Three Speed Modes: Helps adjust the power for small, medium, or tough jobs.
- Tri-Beam LED Lights: Brightens dark spots and cuts shadows so you can see clearly.
- GripZone Handle: Feels soft and steady in hand, even after long use.
- Magnetic Bit Tray: Keeps bits and screws close so you can work faster and stay organized.
- Compact but Strong: Delivers up to 2,200 in-lbs of torque and 3,100 RPM for heavy work.
- One+ Battery Fit: Works with over 225 Ryobi tools, adding value to your set.
The P238 blends comfort, smart features, and strong power. That’s why many people still choose it, even when newer models are out.
What Could Be Better
No tool is perfect. The Ryobi P238 has a few things that users often talk about. These points don’t ruin the experience but are good to know.
Things people might find challenging:
- Battery Use: The power can drain fast under tough or long jobs.
- Weight: It’s a bit heavier and wider than some new Ryobi HP models.
- Heat: Gets warm after long, heavy use.
- Feature Changes: Some newer models removed the magnetic tray and bit holder.
How it can be improved:
- Better cooling design could stop heat build-up.
- Improved battery control could help it run longer under load.
- Bringing back the magnetic tray would make future models more user-friendly.
- A slimmer frame could help reach tight areas.
Even with these small flaws, the P238 still gives great value. It stays reliable for home projects, car work, and light professional use.
My Personal Experience
I explored many reviews, videos, and hands-on tests to learn more about this tool. These thoughts reflect what users often say and what makes the Ryobi brand stand out.
Design
Many people like the simple and solid look of the P238. The Tri-Beam LED lights help you work in low light with fewer shadows. The GripZone handle adds comfort and grip, even when your hands are wet or dusty. The magnetic bit holder keeps screws close, saving time during fast work.
The design still has that bold Ryobi green style that people recognize. It feels strong but not clunky. While it’s a bit larger than new HP models, it gives a confident, steady feel. You can tell it’s made for real work, not just light DIY.
Performance
The P238 gives smooth and steady power for most home and garage jobs. It offers up to 2,200 inch-pounds of torque, which is plenty for long screws or bolts. The three speed settings make it easy to switch between light and heavy work.
Users often say it drives screws fast and clean, with less slipping. The brushless motor keeps power strong and helps the battery last longer. It can get a bit warm during long use, but that’s normal for tools of this size. In general, the P238 runs smoothly and feels strong.
Build Quality
Ryobi is known for solid and lasting tools, and this one fits that image well. The body feels sturdy, with a strong case and firm chuck. The trigger and switches respond well, showing care in design.
Many users say it feels “tough but balanced.” The material doesn’t feel cheap, and it holds up after years of use. It may not be the lightest or most compact, but it’s made to last.
The P238 gives a mix of power, comfort, and dependability. That’s why it remains a good choice for both DIY users and pros who want good performance at a fair price.
Ryobi P237 vs P238: Detailed Comparison
Many users who tried both say the Ryobi P237 and P238 look similar but feel very different. The P237 has a brushed motor, while the P238 uses a brushless one. This single change brings better speed, life, and control. Let’s look at how these two tools compare in power, comfort, and value.
Motor Type (Brushed vs Brushless Influence): Ryobi P237 vs P238
The Ryobi P237 has a brushed motor. The Ryobi P238 comes with a brushless motor. A brushless motor gives smoother speed, less heat, and longer life. The brushed one in the P237 still works well for small jobs but needs more care.
| Feature | Ryobi P237 | Ryobi P238 |
| Motor Type | Brushed | Brushless |
| Efficiency | Moderate | High |
| Maintenance | Needs more | Very little |
| Noise | Louder | Quieter |
Rating: P237 – ⭐ 7.5/10 | P238 – ⭐ 9/10
Power & Torque Output: Ryobi P237 vs P238
The P238 wins when it comes to torque. It has more power and feels faster with each pull of the trigger. The P237 is strong enough for light or home use but struggles with tight bolts.
| Feature | Ryobi P237 | Ryobi P238 |
| Max Torque | ~1,800 in-lbs | ~2,200 in-lbs |
| Power Delivery | Smooth | Strong and instant |
| Ideal For | DIY and small jobs | Heavy work and pro use |
Rating: P237 – ⭐ 7/10 | P238 – ⭐ 9.5/10
Speed Settings & Control: Ryobi P237 vs P238
Both drivers let you control speed with the trigger. The P238, though, feels steadier and faster to respond. Its brushless motor keeps speed even when under load. The P237 works fine but may feel jumpy at low speed.
| Feature | Ryobi P237 | Ryobi P238 |
| Speed Range | 0–3,200 RPM | 0–3,100 RPM (more stable) |
| Control Precision | Average | Excellent |
| Speed Modes | 3 manual modes | 3 smart modes |
Rating: P237 – ⭐ 7/10 | P238 – ⭐ 9/10
Battery Compatibility & Runtime: Ryobi P237 vs P238
Both tools use Ryobi’s 18V ONE+ batteries. You can swap batteries between them. The P238 runs longer on the same battery because of its brushless design. It also wastes less energy.
| Feature | Ryobi P237 | Ryobi P238 |
| Battery Type | 18V ONE+ | 18V ONE+ |
| Runtime | Good | Longer |
| Energy Use | Average | Very efficient |
Rating: P237 – ⭐ 8/10 | P238 – ⭐ 9.5/10
Size & Weight (Ergonomics): Ryobi P237 vs P238
The P238 feels lighter and easier to hold. It stays balanced even with a big battery. The P237 is a bit heavier and feels bulky during long work.
| Feature | Ryobi P237 | Ryobi P238 |
| Weight | About 3.0 lbs | About 2.7 lbs |
| Balance | Slightly top-heavy | Very balanced |
| Comfort | Good | Excellent |
Rating: P237 – ⭐ 7.5/10 | P238 – ⭐ 9/10
Design Features (Grip, Trigger, Switches): Ryobi P237 vs P238
The P238 has a smoother trigger, better grip, and stronger switches. The P237 still feels fine but less refined. You can feel the difference right away when switching tools.
| Feature | Ryobi P237 | Ryobi P238 |
| Grip Texture | Regular rubber | Soft, upgraded rubber |
| Trigger Feel | Average | Smooth and responsive |
| Switch Quality | Good | Strong and firm |
Rating: P237 – ⭐ 7.5/10 | P238 – ⭐ 9/10
LED Work Light Performance: Ryobi P237 vs P238
Both have an LED light near the chuck. The P238’s light is brighter and covers more area. The P237’s light works but feels dim in dark corners.
| Feature | Ryobi P237 | Ryobi P238 |
| Brightness | Fair | Bright |
| Beam Area | Small | Wide |
| Visibility | Okay | Excellent |
Rating: P237 – ⭐ 7/10 | P238 – ⭐ 9/10
Bit Holder & Magnetic Tray: Ryobi P237 vs P238
Both tools include Ryobi’s magnetic tray and bit holder. These are handy for keeping screws close while working. The P238’s magnet feels a bit stronger.
| Feature | Ryobi P237 | Ryobi P238 |
| Bit Holder | Yes | Yes |
| Magnetic Tray | Yes | Yes |
| Magnet Strength | Good | Better |
Rating: P237 – ⭐ 8/10 | P238 – ⭐ 9/10
Durability & Heat Management: Ryobi P237 vs P238
The P238 stays cooler after long use. Its brushless motor spreads heat better and lasts longer. The P237 can get warm if used too long, but it still feels strong and solid.
| Feature | Ryobi P237 | Ryobi P238 |
| Heat Control | Average | Great |
| Build Strength | Solid | Stronger and improved |
| Life Expectancy | Good | Long-lasting |
Rating: P237 – ⭐ 7.5/10 | P238 – ⭐ 9.5/10
Price & Value for Money (2025 Market): Ryobi P237 vs P238
The P237 costs less and offers great value for beginners. The P238 is more expensive but gives better control and life. In 2025, both are still good deals depending on your use.
| Feature | Ryobi P237 | Ryobi P238 |
| Price Range | $50–60 | $90–110 |
| Value for Money | High | Excellent |
| Best Buyer Type | DIY user | Pro or frequent user |
Rating: P237 – ⭐ 8.5/10 | P238 – ⭐ 9/10
Best Use Case (Who Should Buy Which?): Ryobi P237 vs P238
If you work on light home projects, go with the P237. It’s simple, cheap, and still powerful. If you work often or want more control and runtime, choose the P238.
| Type of User | Best Option |
| Home user or beginner | Ryobi P237 |
| Regular or pro user | Ryobi P238 |
Rating: P237 – ⭐ 8/10 | P238 – ⭐ 9.5/10
Final Thoughts on Ryobi
If you like tools that balance power with comfort, Ryobi might be just what you need. The Ryobi P237 vs P238 debate comes down to what matters most — value or performance. The P237 fits casual users who want reliability at a fair price, while the P238 suits those who need more speed and torque for tougher work. Both give solid results without breaking the bank, making Ryobi a trusted pick for many DIY lovers and homeowners alike.
FAQs for Ryobi p237 vs p238
Which is better Ryobi p237 or p238?
Ryobi P238 is better for power and control, while P237 is great for light tasks. If you need more torque and speed, go with the P238.
Does Ryobi p238 have more torque than p237?
Yes, the Ryobi P238 offers more torque and smoother drive. It’s brushless, which means better energy use and longer motor life.
Is the Ryobi p237 still worth buying?
Yes, if you want a low-cost impact driver for small home jobs. It’s light, easy to use, and works well with all Ryobi One+ batteries.
Are Ryobi p237 and p238 batteries interchangeable?
Yes, both use the Ryobi One+ 18V battery system. You can switch batteries between them without any issue or loss in performance.
Which one should I choose for heavy projects?
Pick the Ryobi P238. It’s brushless, runs cooler, and gives steady power for long work hours or tough screws and bolts.
Read More: Ryobi P235 vs P237: The Honest Comparison You Actually Need