My Personal Experience With Both Types of Lawn Mowers

Ever wondered, “Should I get a gas or electric lawn mower?” I’ve been there too. My old gas mower once quit in the middle of a hot summer mow. That pushed me to try an electric one—and let’s just say, it wasn’t all smooth sailing. Over time, I’ve used both and learned what works best. In this guide, I’ll share what I’ve learned so you can choose the right mower for your yard. 

 

Key Differences Between Gas and Electric Lawn Mowers

Power & Performance

When it comes to power, gas mowers usually win. They handle thick or wet grass better and keep going when the yard gets tough. I’ve had times when my electric mower slowed down or stopped completely in tall grass, while my gas mower kept cutting like a champ. Gas mowers are more powerful than electric ones, especially for big jobs or heavy growth.

That said, not every lawn needs that kind of strength. If your yard is small to mid-sized and you mow often, a cordless electric mower can keep up just fine. Newer models have improved a lot, and for regular maintenance cuts, they get the job done without the noise or fumes.

Convenience & Maintenance

This is where electric mowers shine. With my gas mower, I had to yank the cord three or four times just to get it started. On a hot day, that gets old fast. Switching to an electric mower felt like a breath of fresh air—just press a button and go. Electric lawn mowers are easier to start and need less maintenance compared to gas models.

Gas mowers require more attention. You need to change the oil, clean or replace the air filter, check spark plugs, and keep gas on hand. In contrast, electric mowers mostly just need a battery charge and occasional cleaning. No oil, no gas, no mess. If you want something low-effort, electric is the way to go.

Weight and Maneuverability

Let’s talk about weight. Gas mowers are heavy—usually between 60 and 90 pounds. I remember dragging mine up a small hill in the backyard and needing a break halfway through. That thing felt like a gym workout in disguise. Most gas-powered lawn mowers weigh more than electric ones, making them harder to move around.

Electric mowers, especially corded or smaller battery models, are much lighter. My current electric mower weighs under 40 pounds. It’s easy to carry, even up steps or across gravel. If you’re older, smaller in size, or just don’t want to strain your back every weekend, the lighter frame of an electric mower can make mowing way more enjoyable.

Which Is Better – Electric or Gas Lawn Mower?

Not sure which mower to get? You’re not alone. I’ve asked myself the same thing many times. The right choice depends on your yard and how you like to mow.

Gas mowers work well for big yards. They also do better in thick grass or rough spots. I used one when I had a large lawn. It never ran out of power and could cut through anything.

Electric mowers shine in small or medium yards. They are light, quiet, and easy to start. Just press a button and go. I love using mine when I need a fast, quiet mow.

If you hate gas smell or loud engines, go electric. If you want more power and don’t mind noise, gas is still a strong pick.

Here’s a quick look at how they compare:

Feature	Gas Mower	Electric Mower
Best for	Big yards, thick or wet grass	Small lawns, light mowing
Noise	Loud	Quiet
Start method	Pull cord	Push button
Maintenance	More (oil, filter, gas)	Less (just charge and clean)
Weight	Heavy	Light
Run time	As long as you have fuel	Limited battery or cord
Eco-friendly	No	Yes

If you want a mower that’s quiet, light, and easy to use, go with electric. If your lawn is big or rough, a gas mower will serve you better.

What Are the Disadvantages of an Electric Lawn Mower?

Electric mowers are great—until they’re not. I’ve loved mine, but I’ve also hit some snags. Let me walk you through the downsides, so you know what to expect before you plug one in.

Cordless mowers don’t run forever.

Most batteries last about 30 to 60 minutes. If your yard is big or you take mowing breaks (like I do to sip lemonade), that time can fly by. I’ve had my mower die with one strip left. Super annoying.
Short run-time is the biggest con of cordless electric lawn mowers.

Corded mowers have their own issues.

You’ve got to drag a long extension cord everywhere. I’ve tripped over mine more than once—and let’s not even talk about almost mowing the cord (yep, I’ve done it).
Managing a long cord while mowing can be a hassle and even a safety risk.

Batteries wear out.

After a couple of years, mine didn’t hold a charge like it used to. Replacing a battery can cost a lot—sometimes close to the price of a whole new mower.
Battery lifespan and replacement cost are major downsides of electric lawn mowers.

Charging takes time.

You can’t just fuel up and go like with gas. If you forget to charge the battery the night before? You’re out of luck. And not every outdoor space has an outlet nearby.
Charging time and power access can delay your mowing plans.

Cost Comparison – Upfront and Over Time

Let’s talk cost. A lawn mower is a big buy, so it helps to know what you’re getting into. When I bought my first mower, I was shocked by the price gap.
Electric mowers are often cheaper to buy than gas ones.

I got a corded electric mower for about half the price of a gas mower. That felt like a win. But cost doesn’t stop there. Gas mowers need fuel, oil, spark plugs, and filters. I made more than a few gas station runs—and those add up fast.
Gas mowers need more money for fuel and parts over time.

Electric mowers run on power from the wall or a battery. That’s much cheaper than gas. I barely notice a change on my power bill. No oil changes. No spark plugs. Just plug in the charger and go.
Electric mowers cost less to run and need less upkeep.

But there’s one catch—batteries. Mine worked great at first. But after two summers, it started to fade. A new battery was pricey. Some cost almost as much as a whole mower!
Battery life and cost can be a downside with electric mowers.

Here’s the bottom line:

• Electric mowers are great if you want to spend less now and later.
• Gas mowers cost more but give strong power for big jobs.
• If you have a small yard, electric is the easy win.
• For bigger lawns, gas might be worth the higher cost.

Electric is budget-friendly and easy. Gas is strong but comes with more costs.

Are Gas or Electric Lawn Mowers Better for the Environment?

Yes—electric lawn mowers are better for the planet than gas ones.

Carbon Emissions

Gas mowers burn fuel. That means they release smoke and fumes into the air. I used to smell it every time I mowed. It stuck to my clothes and made me cough.

Later, I read that gas mowers can pollute as much as a car on a long drive. That shocked me.

Electric mowers don’t burn fuel. They run on power from a wall or battery. They don’t release smoke or gas while you use them.

Electric mowers don’t make emissions while mowing. Gas mowers do.

Noise Pollution

Gas mowers are loud. Really loud. Mine sounded like a bike with no muffler. My dog would hide, and the neighbors were not fans.

Electric mowers are much quieter. Mine sounds more like a fan. I can even hear birds while I mow now.

Electric mowers are quiet. Gas mowers make a lot of noise.

Battery vs. Fuel Waste

Electric mowers use batteries. Over time, the battery gets weak and must be replaced. You can’t throw it in the trash. It needs to be recycled.

Gas mowers need oil and gas. I’ve spilled both before. It made a mess, and I worried about it hurting the grass.

Electric mowers need battery care. Gas mowers create fuel waste.

What Is the Best Type of Lawn Mower for You?

Short answer: The best lawn mower depends on your yard, your needs, and your lifestyle. Let’s break it down so you can decide with confidence.

Lawn Size

If you’ve got a big lawn, a gas mower might still be your best bet. They run as long as you’ve got fuel, and they power through thick grass like it’s nothing. I used one when I had a big backyard—it never gave up, even on long summer days.

But for small or mid-sized yards, electric mowers are easier. No fuel runs, no oil changes, just a push of a button. I’ve been using mine in a small yard for years, and it’s a dream—quiet, quick, and hassle-free.

Big yard? Go gas. Small yard? Electricity is enough.

Budget

Let’s be real—money matters. When I first looked for a mower, the price tags gave me sticker shock. Gas mowers cost more upfront and even more later (think: gas, oil, filters).

Electric mowers—especially corded ones—are usually cheaper. Even the cordless kind often pay off long-term. I’ve barely spent a dime on mine since I bought it. Just some soap and a brush now and then.

Electric mowers cost less now and later. Gas mowers cost more but offer raw power.

Physical Strength

Gas mowers are heavy. I used to wrestle mine uphill like I was training for a fitness test. If you’re older, smaller in size, or just want to take it easy—electric wins.

My current mower is light enough to carry with one hand. I actually enjoy mowing now, and I don’t end up sore the next day.

Electric is lighter and easier on the body. Gas can feel like a workout.

Eco-Consciousness

If you care about the environment, electric mowers are the clear choice. No fumes, less noise, and less mess. When I switched, I felt good knowing I wasn’t sending smoke into the sky every weekend.

Yes, batteries need care and recycling—but it still beats the smell of gas and the guilt of spills.

Electric mowers are better for the earth—less pollution, less noise.

Neighborhood Noise Rules

Some places have rules about noise. Trust me—your neighbors notice when you crank up a gas mower at 7 AM on a Sunday.

Electric mowers are so quiet I can mow while the baby’s napping. True story. Birds kept singing while I worked. It’s peaceful, and nobody gives you the stink-eye.

Electric is quiet and neighbor-friendly. Gas can stir up unwanted attention.

Final Tip: Match Your Mower to Your Life

Here’s a quick cheat sheet to help:

Factor	Best Pick
Big yard, thick grass	Gas mower
Small or mid-sized yard	Electric mower
Tight budget	Electric mower
Want low upkeep	Electric mower
Need strong power	Gas mower
Concerned about the planet	Electric mower
Need quiet operation	Electric mower

 

Bottom line: Pick the mower that fits your yard and your lifestyle. I’ve used both. And I can tell you—choosing the right one makes mowing less of a chore and more of a breeze.

Want help picking one that fits your needs? I’m just a comment away. 😊

FAQs – Your Lawn Mower Questions Answered

Which is better, an electric or gas lawn mower?

It depends on your yard.
Gas mowers are stronger. They cut thick grass with ease.
Electric mowers are lighter and quieter. They’re easy to start too.

If your lawn is big or rough, go gas. For small, smooth yards, go electric.

Are electric mowers powerful enough for thick grass?

Sometimes yes, sometimes no.
For light mowing, they work great. But tall or wet grass? That’s a challenge.
I’ve had mine stop halfway through a tough patch.

Electric mowers can handle light jobs, but gas works better for thick growth.

Can I mow a large yard with an electric mower?

You can—but it takes planning.
Cordless ones may run out of power before you’re done.
Corded ones need a long extension cord.

Electric mowers can cut big lawns, but gas makes it easier.

How long do electric mower batteries last?

Most last 30 to 60 minutes per charge.
That’s enough for a small yard.
But if you pause often (like I do), you might run out before you finish.

Plan for short mowing sessions or keep a spare battery on hand

What is the average weight of a gas lawn mower?

Most gas mowers weigh 60 to 90 pounds.
They’re strong but heavy. I used to sweat just pulling mine up a slope.
Electric ones? Much lighter—some are under 40 pounds.

Gas mowers are heavier. Electric mowers are easier to lift and push.

Final Thoughts – What I’d Recommend (Based on Real Use)

So, should you go gas or electric?

After using both for years, here’s my honest advice—like I’d give to a friend over coffee.

If you’re buying your first mower, I say start simple. Go electric. It’s lighter, quieter, and easier to use. No oil, no gas, no pulling cords like you’re starting a lawn tractor. Just push a button and mow. That alone makes mowing feel less like a chore and more like a quick task you can knock out on a weekend morning.

First-time buyers? Go electric—it’s easy, quiet, and stress-free.

But gas mowers do have their place. If your yard is big, wild, or full of thick grass, gas still wins. There were days my electric mower just couldn’t keep up. It slowed down or stopped mid-strip. But my old gas mower? That thing was a beast—it didn’t care if the grass was wet, tall, or tangled.

Big, tough yards? Gas mowers power through without slowing down.

Now, here’s where it gets personal. Over time, I’ve found that ease matters more than raw power. I used to love the sound of the engine revving up—but now I just want a peaceful mow. Something that starts fast and doesn’t make my arms sore the next day. My electric mower gives me that.

Long-term satisfaction? For me, electric wins for comfort and ease.

If I had to sum it up:

• Gas is like a pickup truck—strong, reliable, but heavy and loud.
• Electric is like a hybrid car—quiet, clean, and perfect for everyday use.

In the end, it’s not about which one sounds better—it’s about what fits your yard, your time, and your lifestyle.

Choose the mower that makes mowing feel easy—not exhausting.

Still unsure? Think about how big your lawn is, how much time you want to spend on maintenance, and whether noise or fumes will bother you—or your neighbors.

And if you ever need help deciding, feel free to reach out. I’ve been through both sides and I’m happy to help you find your perfect match.

Read More: How to Dispose of a Gas Powered Lawn Mower